Page 1 of 1

context - Delete Form dialog version 528

PostPosted: Sun Sep 11, 2011 5:00 pm
by JvNoort
Hello,

On context - deleteform in vs. 528:
Maybe it's just me but i find it irritating that if i want to delete a form i expect info before the actual delete.

But this isn't the case : Its just ""Do you want to delete the form?"
That is not sensible to me! :evil:

I would expect: "Do you really want to delete form: "frmName so and So" ?
So no one get's mixed up on which form is clicked.

Regards, Jan

Re: context - Delete Form dialog version 528

PostPosted: Sun Sep 11, 2011 7:40 pm
by ROCLASI
While we are on the topic of UX. Can the dialogs also have proper named buttons?
The caption 'OK' doesn't say much. A more appropriate caption would be 'Delete' or even better 'Delete Form'.

Re: context - Delete Form dialog version 528

PostPosted: Tue Sep 13, 2011 10:39 am
by rgansevles
Makes sense, please file a feature request in our support system.

Rob

Re: context - Delete Form dialog version 528

PostPosted: Tue Sep 13, 2011 3:20 pm
by jcompagner
i am not convinced about renaming the buttons
Because that is something eclipse by itself also doesn't do
just click in the navigator on a file and say delete:
Then you also get the ok and cancel buttons with the question to confirm the delete of file 'x' (naming the file is better yes)

Re: context - Delete Form dialog version 528

PostPosted: Wed Sep 14, 2011 9:40 am
by ROCLASI
jcompagner wrote:i am not convinced about renaming the buttons
Because that is something eclipse by itself also doesn't do

And 2 wrongs make a right ? ;)

jcompagner wrote:just click in the navigator on a file and say delete:
Then you also get the ok and cancel buttons with the question to confirm the delete of file 'x' (naming the file is better yes)


:twisted: You could also use a dialog with: 'Cancel' and 'Don't Cancel'.
Because the dialog tekst already explained what it does, right ? :twisted:

Just trying to make a point ;)
The button caption matters a lot.

Re: context - Delete Form dialog version 528

PostPosted: Wed Sep 14, 2011 9:54 am
by ROCLASI
Case #416578 submitted (for both dialog text and button captions).

Re: context - Delete Form dialog version 528

PostPosted: Wed Sep 14, 2011 11:11 am
by jcompagner
The user interface should just be consistent, throughout the app, so it should do what eclipse does. Also I think that ok,cancel (or yes,no) is common.

If you where the system and you ask me "should I delete form X?" Then I would answer 'ok' or 'yes'. I wouldn't answer 'delete'